I tried to cure this once with a lesson in pancake wrapping that I used as my performance in the LCFD Dance Camp variety show (we explicitly don't call it a talent show). It wasn't effective; I still do the wrapping.
Recently to demonstrate how easy it is, I've tried doing it different ways. Blindfolded worked pretty well - the result looked as good as normal. It was a bit difficult finding the box of waxed paper though since it is stored among other similar boxes of other wrappings. I tried it with one hand; there was a bit of difficulty keeping the folds down while reaching for the end of the waxed paper. I've yet to try it with my left hand. Yesterday I tried it with two hands behind my back. It didn't work too well; the paper got kind of crumpled up and there is a small gap in the wrapping where you can see a waffle and at one point one of the waffles seemed to get slightly folded up. It was hampered a bit by a slightly crowded counter. I'll have to try this again - it was easier with pancakes than waffles because they are a bit smaller so I will wait until they are up. If this is successful I guess one hand behind my back might be next.